H eadlines
Social Continued from Page 1
those programs and dedicated
her career to developing robust
social safety nets.

After graduating from
Wellesley College in 1915,
Kahn was inspired by a family
friend to pursue a career in
social work. She became
a case worker at the Jewish
Family Agency from 1915 to
1918, attended the University
of Chicago School of Social
Work (now the School of Social
Service Administration) and
worked as civic director of
Chicago Women’s Aid.

In 1919, she was offered
a job at Hebrew Benevolent
Association of Baltimore
and worked there until 1928,
when she became director of
the Jewish Welfare Society of
Philadelphia. Kahn helmed this organi-
zation at a time when social
work — particularly Jewish
social work — was undergoing
profound changes because of
the Great Depression. Rugged
individualism and private
charity proved inadequate in
the face of mass unemploy-
ment, poverty and hunger,
leading President Franklin
Delano Roosevelt to create the
social welfare programs known
10 NOVEMBER 26, 2020
wisely. For if relief represents
frustration, failure and inade-
quacy, can it nourish and
rehabilitate its recipients? And
if it is too readily accepted as
due recompense for lost oppor-
tunity, does it cripple initiative
and undermine the spirit of
independence?” she wrote
in Annals of the American
Academy of Political and
Social Science.

She used
empathetic Dorothy C. Kahn
Photo via womeninpeace.org
and the West India Co. admitted
them on the condition that they
would care for the poor in their
community. “This was something that
Jewish social workers turned
from a mandate that allowed
their settlement in colonial
America into an obligation
that Jews ‘take care of their
own,’ and the Great Depression
really made that impossible,”
Wenger said.

on employment and relief of
Roosevelt’s Committee on
Economic Security.

She lived and worked in
Philadelphia until 1945 and
received widespread support
from Philadelphians after she
was fired from the local relief
board, according to Ditzion.

She went on to work for the
American Association of Social
Workers as staff executive secre-
tary and then staff president.

Jewish social workers and professionals continued to believe in the
ideal of ethnic philanthropy as a kind of cornerstone of Jewish life.”
BETH WENGER
collectively as the New Deal.

Kahn believed all citizens
deserved relief. However, she
knew that Americans’ desire to
believe in meritocracy, or “the
American success psychology,”
as she put it, made welfare
controversial. “This is important because
it has produced a set of
mind which surrounds relief
with emotional conflicts of
enormous importance to
those who would administer it
portrayals of people who
sought public relief to argue
that they were in need due to
forces outside of their control
and were entitled to support as
a matter of justice.

“Kahn urged social workers
and the social work profes-
sion to take leadership roles
in developing and building
an adequate national system
for social welfare,” clinical
geriatric social worker and
author Joan Ditzion wrote
in Kahn’s biography for the
Jewish Women’s Archive.

With the expansion of
public welfare agencies during
the New Deal, Jewish social
services, in particular, had to
reckon with their roles in their
communities and American
society at large.

Beth Wenger, associate dean
for graduate studies and Moritz
and Josephine Berg Professor
of History at the University of
Pennsylvania, said Jewish social
workers struggled with the
fact that they could no longer
fulfill the Stuyvesant Promise,
a colonial compact that had a
strong influence over Jewish
American charity. When
the first Jews came to New
Amsterdam (now Manhattan)
in 1654, Gov. Peter Stuyvesant
JEWISH EXPONENT
Despite the upheaval, Jewish
social workers like Kahn saw
the need for national public
relief efforts and did not view
their work in conflict with New
Deal relief programs like the
Social Security Agency and the
Civil Works Administration.

Many joined expanding
government agencies, while
others continued to address
need in Jewish contexts.

“Jewish social workers and
professionals continued to
believe in the ideal of ethnic
philanthropy as a kind of
cornerstone of Jewish life. Even
after the government assumed
responsibility for
many programs, they focused on
things that were within their
realm in Jewish employment
services, dealing with Jewish
families, vocational guidance,
all sorts of things that they
felt could still be done under
Jewish auspices,” Wenger said.

Kahn’s career spanned the
Jewish and non-Jewish social
work worlds. She became
the first executive director
of the Philadelphia County
Relief Board in 1932, served
as president of the American
Association of Social Workers
from 1934 to 1936 and
chaired the subcommittee
“In these positions, she
developed professional
standards for public welfare
workers and helped the social
work profession define its role
in the development of social
policy and social welfare
programs across the country,”
Ditzion wrote.

In the early 1940s, she
served as director of Economic
Adjustment and Family Services
at the National Refugee Service
in New York. After World
War II, she became the execu-
tive director of the Health
and Welfare Council of New
York City. She was chief of the
Social Welfare Division of the
Department of Social Affairs of
the United Nations from 1951
to 1954 and advised the Israeli
government on social welfare
legislation. She died on Aug. 26, 1955 in
New Hope.

“She believed that people
were in need through no fault
of their own, and that every
citizen had the right to a
minimum standard of living
as a matter of human rights
and social justice, not charity,”
Ditzion wrote. l
spanzer@jewishexponent.com; 215-832-0729
JEWISHEXPONENT.COM



F TAY-SACHS
R F R E E E E
H eadlines
& & TAY-SACHS
CANAVAN CANAVAN
SCREENING SCREENING
Schools Continued from Page 1
It’s the second Sunday
the protesters have come to
make their voices heard here:
Arkoosh is the chair of the
Montgomery County Board
of Commissioners, and the
Montgomery County Board
of Health announced on Nov.

13 that all K-12 schools would
close for two weeks in the face
of an unprecedented spike in
COVID-19 cases.

Many members of the
Jewish community were
outraged by the decision, and
decided to fight back. A Lower
Merion Jewish parents listserv
touted the Sunday morning
protest, urging, “Make your
voice heard by participating.”
On Nov. 22, protest organizer
Jaret Gale, who is not Jewish,
said his efforts have been
strongly supported by the
Jewish community, and that
the owner of a Jewish day care
was one of the first people on
the scene.

Gale choked back tears as he
spoke to the Exponent about
his opposition to the school
closure. In the spring, he said, he
found a note written by his
teenage daughter, in which she
expressed a desire to commit
suicide in concert with a few
friends. The shock of the
pandemic and the isolation of
at-home schooling had pushed
her to her breaking point. She’s
feeling all right now, but Gale
remains on constant edge.

“As a parent, I can’t sit back
and watch that happen anymore,”
Gale said. “I just can’t do it.”
The Board of Health’s
5-0 decision to mandate the
two-week closure, made with
guidance from CHOP PolicyLab,
has also rankled leaders of Jewish
day schools in Montgomery
County, along with the parents
and students they serve.

Parents at Kohelet Yeshiva
received an email on Nov. 17
from Rabbi Gil Perl, head of
school. Acknowledging “the
rising prevalence of COVID-19
JEWISHEXPONENT.COM in our area,” Perl nonetheless
expressed disappointment
that schools appeared to have
been given no ability to apply
for an exemption from the
order, based on precautionary
measures or rates of in-school
transmission. Additionally, he wrote, the
fact that the order failed to
distinguish between school
for students K-5 and schools
with students in grades 6-12
“was similarly difficult for us
to curb the spread of COVID-19,
including wearing masks and
engaging in social distancing,”
Troodler wrote on Nov. 13,
“I cannot in good conscience
endorse a nonsensical directive
that unnecessarily and unjustly
impacts my children in an
adverse fashion.”
Audrey Gornish, mother
of three Kohelet students, was
more succinct.

“It’s absolutely ridiculous,”
she said.

they were closing schools when
they were leaving open restau-
rants and gyms and bowling
alleys and all these other places
where we know that there’s
been transmission of disease,”
she said.

Daniel, Kleinman’s sixth-
grade son, has enjoyed his time
away from Zoom school.

“I get to play recess and get
outside,” he said.

Montgomery County Judge
Richard Haaz denied an order
CALL (215) 887-0877
FOR DETAILS
e-mail: ntsad@aol.com;
visit: www.tay-sachs.org
■ Screening for other
Jewish Genetic Diseases
also available.

This message is sponsored by a friend of
Nat’l Tay-Sachs & Allied Diseases
Association of Delaware Valley
They always say, ‘Follow the science.’ The school is following the science. So I’ve kind of
lost faith in people that want to make those types of decisions.”
AUDREY GORNISH
to understand.” Perl informed
parents that a letter was
submitted to the board, with
the support of the school’s
Medical Advisory Committee,
requesting flexibility or an
exemption for the K-5 students.

The Montgomery County
Board of Health did not
respond to multiple requests
for comment. Arkoosh, for
her part, has responded to the
protests that have taken place
outside her house:
“As a parent, I understand
that the past 37 weeks have been
extremely difficult for everyone
in our community, and I respect
these parents for advocating for
what they believe is best for their
children,” she said in a statement
distributed to media outlets. “I
want to make clear that I want
in-person school to continue,
and based on our data in
Montgomery County, our team
believes this five- to eight-day
pause in in-person schooling
will support this goal.”
Kohelet parent Nachi
Troodler was one of those who
objected to that pause. Writing
in his publication Philadelphia
Jewish Link, Troodler expressed
the anger felt by many.

“While we should all be fully
supportive of measures intended
If kids had been “dropping
like flies,” Gornish said, then
the decision would’ve made
sense to her. It was the fact
that no allowance was made
for schools to be judged on
a case-by-case basis, she said,
that she was objecting to. Her
children experienced distance
learning once already and, with
the weirdness of the spring, it
just seemed like what one had
to do. But now that they’ve
been back in school, the idea of
returning to distance learning
is devastating.

“They always say, ‘Follow
the science,’” Gornish said.

“The school is following the
science. So I’ve kind of lost
faith in people that want to
make those types of decisions.”
Deborah Kleinman’s
children are split between
the Morris and Rose Caskey
Torah Academy of Greater
Philadelphia and Kohelet.

What they’re not split on is
a desire to remain in school,
where they’ve been able to
see their teachers and friends
in person since school began
again in the fall. Their mother
doesn’t feel any particular
tension when it comes to her
assessment, either.

“I was sort of surprised that
JEWISH EXPONENT
on Nov. 20 by parents seeking
to stop the board’s directive,
according to the Inquirer. A
second lawsuit has been filed in
federal court.

Despite the protests, public
health officials — and a signif-
icant portion of the population
— back the restrictions. They
note that new cases of COVID-19
in Pennsylvania have roughly
tripled since the end of October
and that similar restrictions
are being implemented across
the country.

Barbara Wadsworth, a
member of the Montgomery
County Board of Health and
senior VP of patient services
and chief nursing officer at
Main Line Health, told The
Philadelphia Inquirer, “If we
don’t do this, we will be in
a significantly worse situation
post-Thanksgiving holiday.” l
jbernstein@jewishexponent.com; 215-832-0740
Don’t Schlep It, Ship It! Free Pick Up Available!
No matter whether it’s golf clubs, good china,
priceless art, oversized luggage –
if you can point to it, we can ship it!
If it’s valuable to you, it’s valuable to us. The
US Mailroom picks up, packs, and ships items
of all shapes and sizes, getting your packages
from where they are to where they need to be.

We cater especially to “snowbirds” as the cold
weather approaches.

Call us today at 610-668-4182
or visit our store in Bala Cynwyd, PA.

For more information,
email info@usmailroom.com
or go to www.usmailroom.com
Est.1988 NOVEMBER 26, 2020
11