opinion
Jewish Tradition ‘Permits’
Abortion. If You Believe in Bodily
Autonomy, That’s Not Enough
BY MICHAL RAUCHER
E arlier this month, Israeli Health Minister Nitzan
Horowitz responded to the draft U.S. Supreme
Court opinion that would overturn Roe v. Wade, “A
woman’s rights over her own body are hers alone.”
It might seem odd that the Israeli health minister
was commenting on American abortion law, but
his response, contained in a tweet, addresses
a theme common to the abortion discussion in
Israel and America that I research as an ethicist
and scholar of reproduction among Jews.

In the 1970s, the Israeli Knesset debated the
legalization of abortion. After several years of dis-
cussions, it ultimately passed a law that permitted
abortion in certain circumstances: 1) If a woman is
younger than 17 or older than 40; 2) when preg-
nancy results from rape, incest or extramarital
relations; 3) under the possibility that the baby will
be born with a physical or mental deformity; and
4) when the continuation of the pregnancy could
endanger a woman’s life or mental health. This
law allows for certain abortions to be performed
until the 39th week of pregnancy.

When I teach Americans about abortion law in
Israel, they often express shock that Israel seems
much more progressive than America. That’s
because their frame of reference for religion
and abortion is a particular strain of American
anti-abortion Christianity. My students — col-
lege-aged and adult, Jewish or not — are sur-
prised to see a country so strongly influenced by
religion that is not opposed to abortion.

Yet in one important way the Israeli and
American attitudes toward abortion are similar.

They both reflect the fundamental assumption
that abortion is wrong, and one must have a “good
enough” reason to do something that is otherwise
wrong. This is called the justification approach
to abortion. Certain abortions are justified, while
others are not. The justification approach to abor-
tion also assumes that women were meant to be
mothers. As a result, not wanting to be pregnant
for nine months, give birth or raise a child are
not considered good enough reasons to get an
abortion. In order to qualify for an abortion that is legal
and paid for by the state, Israeli women have to sit
in front of a committee and tell them why they are
requesting an abortion. Although 98% of abortion
requests are approved, the law reflects the belief
16 MAY 26, 2022 | JEWISHEXPONENT.COM
that women cannot or should not make this deci-
sion on their own.

Consider the case of a pregnant 24-year-old
married woman who is pregnant from consensual
sex but does not want to be pregnant because of
the potential harm to her career. Or a 35-year-old
married haredi (ultra-Orthodox) woman who has
eight children and who simply cannot care for
one more. In Israel, both of these women must lie
or otherwise mislead the committee to get their
abortions. Horowitz opposes these committees and has
been advocating to get rid of them, at least
through the first trimester. He says that women
should not need to give any reason for their
request, and that nobody should have to deter-
mine whether their request is valid.

There’s a temptation right
now to say that
restrictions on abortion
rights in the United States
violate the religious
freedom of Jews.

While we don’t have these committees in
America, we have heard a lot this month about
the legislation that many states have developed,
each providing different circumstances under
which they would permit abortion. Some say that
abortions will only be permitted if the woman’s
life is in danger. Others allow abortion after rape
or incest. And of course one’s ability to terminate
a pregnancy is already limited by where one lives,
how far along one is in pregnancy and the finan-
cial resources one has available.

Well-meaning Jewish groups often draw on rab-
binic sources to claim that Judaism is supportive
of abortion rights. Unfortunately here, too, we see
the justification approach. Last week, in a state-
ment, the Orthodox Union explained that it cannot
support an “absolute ban” on abortion because
Jewish law requires abortion when “carrying the
pregnancy to term poses real risk to the life of the
mother.” This popular argument is commonly also
heard among more progressive Jewish groups.

But when you hear that “Jewish law permits and
sometimes requires abortion,” you must also lis-
ten to the assumption underlying this statement:
Women do not have the bodily autonomy to make
that decision on their own. Jewish law must per-
mit it — and sometimes demands it, regardless of
what a woman prefers. These statements, often
used to express support for abortion rights, are
ultimately stymied by the assumptions of rabbinic
law, a system that does not support bodily auton-
omy or the ability to make decisions about one’s
own body.

The statement by the Orthodox Union goes
even further. It also explicitly prohibits what the
group and others call “abortion on demand,” or
abortion because someone doesn’t want to be
pregnant. By contrast, the Reform movement’s Religious
Action Center bases its position on reproductive
rights on “the core belief that each person should
have agency and autonomy over their own bod-
ies.” Other progressive Jewish groups, including
the National Council of Jewish Women, have
gone on record highlighting the value of bodily
autonomy over reproduction, but too few. Some
non-Orthodox rabbis even expressly forbid it.

Unless you support a person’s right to bodily
autonomy, then you are supporting a system
wherein someone else determines what you or
anyone else can do with their bodies. It does
not matter whether that person is a lawmaker, a
judge, a contemporary rabbi or one from 2,000
years ago. It does not matter whether that per-
son would permit most abortions or even require
some. There’s a temptation right now to say that
restrictions on abortion rights in the United States
violate the religious freedom of Jews. That’s true,
to an extent. But a religious argument based on
Jewish law and rabbinic texts only goes so far.

Those of us who support reproductive health,
rights and justice ought to be honest about the
connection between that and our rabbinic tradi-
tion. I believe in the same bodily autonomy argu-
ment that Nitzan Horowitz makes. It may not be an
argument rooted in Jewish law, but it is a Jewish
argument — and it’s time to make it. JE
Michal Raucher is an associate professor of
Jewish studies at Rutgers University and author
of “Conceiving Agency: Reproductive Authority
Among Haredi Women” (Indiana University Press).




nation / world
Jewish Groups Fail to Stop Arizona from Gas Chamber Executions
An unusual scenario played out in Arizona recently: The son of a Jewish woman
who fled the Nazis was asked if he wanted to be executed by the same gas the
Nazis once used, JTA reported.

Frank Atwood, who was convicted of murdering an 8-year-old girl in 1984,
has been on death row for decades. For his method of execution he was given the
choice between lethal injection, Arizona’s default method, or a gas chamber —
which the state refurbished last year in preparation for possibly killing Atwood
and one other death row inmate.

Arizona’s intent to restart gas executions, and the state’s purchase of materials
to make hydrogen cyanide — a version of which, Zyklon B, was used by the Nazis
to murder Jews in Auschwitz — is strongly opposed by its Jewish community.

In February, the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Phoenix and
two members of the Jewish community partnered with the local American Civil
Liberties Union chapter to sue the state over its planned use of the gas, calling the
punishment “cruel and inhumane.”
A superior court judge threw out the suit in April, saying that the Jewish com-
munity had failed to sufficiently challenge the law’s constitutionality, and that the
state’s constitution permits execution by gas in some cases.

Chad Restores Full Diplomatic Relations with Israel
Israel has an ambassador to Chad for the first time in 50 years, adding to Israel’s
growing ties to African countries, JTA reported.

Ben Bourgel, who serves as a nonresident ambassador to several African
countries, added Chad to his list on May 17 when he presented his credentials to
Chad’s president, Mahamat Idriss Déby Itno.

Several African nations whose leaders had friendly relations with Israel severed
those ties in the 1970s, following pressure by Arab nations. Former Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu prioritized restoring diplomatic ties with many of
them, and he met with Chad’s former president, Idriss Déby Itno, in 2018.

The Israeli ambassador and his team “will work to strengthen the cooperation
between the two countries in areas of common interest such as climate change,
agriculture, water management and health,” the Israeli embassy in Dakar,
Senegal, wrote on Twitter about Bourgel’s accreditation.

Exclusive Women’s Apparel Boutique
Made in USA
Custom designs, color options and
free alterations available
Evening Gowns
Suits/Separates Cocktail Dresses
61 Buck Road
Huntingdon Valley,
PA 19006
www.elanaboutique.com (215)953-8820
Make an appointment
to consult with the designer
Monday-Friday 10am-3pm
Boris Johnson Vows to Solve Northern Ireland’s Kosher Food Shortages
During a visit to a synagogue in Belfast, British Prime Minister Boris Johnson
promised to fix bureaucratic complications connected to Brexit that have caused
kosher food shortages in Northern Ireland, JTA reported.

There is no need for “laborious checks on products uniquely important to
the Jewish community being moved from Great Britain into Northern Ireland,”
Johnson said. “We will see this situation resolved.”
Northern Ireland has remained in the European Union’s single market even
though the United Kingdom, of which Northern Ireland is a part, pulled out of
the bloc in 2020. This fact has complicated shipments of food and other products
from the United Kingdom to Northern Ireland, resulting in kosher food short-
ages, among other issues.

The Jewish community of Manchester in England is the main kosher food
supplier for the Belfast Jewish Community Synagogue, which services that com-
munity of a few hundred people.

90-year-old Jewish Man Allegedly Pushed to His Death
in Lyon, France
A dispute between neighbors in France ended with the death of a 90-year-old Jewish
man, according to police, who do not suspect an antisemitic motive, JTA reported.

Police arrested a 51-year-old neighbor of the deceased, René Hadjaj, sometime
after Hadjaj’s death on May 17 outside his home in Lyon in eastern France, the
Tribune Juive Jewish newspaper reported. The suspect pushed Hadjaj to his death
from an elevated story of their residential building, prosecutors told Le Progrès.

That paper reported that police first investigated a possible antisemitic motive
but have now excluded it. French media have not reported the suspect’s identity. JE
— Compiled by Andy Gotlieb
FREE ESTIMATES
PERSONALIZED SERVICE
SENIOR DOWNSIZING
DECLUTTER / HOARDING CLEAN OUTS
ALL ITEMS SOLD, DONATED, OR REPURPOSED
RESPECTFUL OF HOMES WITH
ACCUMULATIONS OF 30+ YEARS
JOLIE OMINSKY
OWNER SERVING PA, DE, NJ
JOCSERNICA@YAHOO.COM 610-551-3105
JEWISHEXPONENT.COM 17