Jewish Exponent
PHILADELPHIA Publisher & Chief Executive Offi cer
Craig Burke
cburke@midatlanticmedia.com Associate Publisher
Jeni Mann Tough
jmann@midatlanticmedia.com EDITORIAL
Editor | Andy Gotlieb
215-832-0797 agotlieb@jewishexponent.com
Staff Writers
Jillian Diamond, Sasha Rogelberg,
Heather Ross, Jarrad Saffren
ADVERTISING Account Executives
Alan Gurwitz, Robin Harmon,
Pam Kuperschmidt, Jodi Lipson,
David Pintzow, Sara Priebe,
Sharon Schmuckler, Samantha Tuttle,
Sylvia Witaschek
MARKETING Audience Development Coordinator
Julia Olaguer
410-902-2308 jolaguer@midatlanticmedia.com
CREATIVE Art Director | Steve Burke
Graphic Designers | Ebony Brown,
Lonna Koblick, Jay Sevidal,
Frank Wagner, Carl Weigel
Digital Media Coordinator
James Meskunas
7605 Old York Road, Melrose Park, PA 19027
Vol. 135, No. 37 Published Weekly Since 1887
BUSINESS Accounting Manager
Pattie-Ann Lamp
410-902-2311 plamp@midatlanticmedia.com
accounting@midatlanticmedia.com Senior Accounts Receivable Specialist
Jessica McGinnis
jmcginnis@midatlanticmedia.com Accounts Receivable Specialist
Sarah Appelbaum
sappelbaum@midatlanticmedia.com Main Offi ce: 215-832-0700
editor@jewishexponent.com 215-832-0797
circulation@jewishexponent.com 215-832-0700, ext. 1
sales@jewishexponent.com 215-832-0700, ext. 2
classifi ed@jewishexponent.com
215-832-0749 Connect with us:
Legal Notices
legals@jewishexponent.com If you’re having problems receiving your Philadelphia Jewish Exponent in the mail,
and live in an apartment or suite, please contact our circulation department at
215-832-0700, ext. 1, or circulation@jewishexponent.com.

JEWISH EXPONENT, a Mid-Atlantic Media publication, is published weekly since 1887 with a special issue in September (ISSN 0021-6437) ©2022 Jewish Exponent (all rights
reserved). Periodical postage paid in Philadelphia, PA, and additional offices. Postmaster: All address changes should be sent to Jewish Exponent Circulation Dept., 9200 Rumsey Road,
Suite 215, Columbia, MD 21045. A one-year subscription is $50, 2 years, $100. Foreign rates on request.

Jewish Exponent does not endorse kashrut claims. To verify the kashrut of goods or services advertised in Jewish Exponent, readers should consult rabbinic authorities. The Jewish Exponent
reserves the right to revise, reject or edit any advertisement.

NOW OPEN!
Elevated senior living...

with just the right
amount of care.

Personal Care & Memory Care Living
An LCB Senior Living Community:
More Than 25 Years of Excellence
Select apartments still available at
our special Now Open Rate!
610-200-6792 | residencebalacynwyd.com
2 DECEMBER 15, 2022 | JEWISHEXPONENT.COM



THIS WEEK
Local 6 Josh Shapiro Transitions to Governor’s Office
7 Beth Chaim Reform Congregation Selling Banned Books
8 Congregation Beth Israel Celebrates Chanukah by Conserving
Energy Via Solar Panels
Opinion 12 Editorials
13 Letters
13 Opinions
Happy Chanukah
FROM LAUREL HILL
Feature Story
17 A Symbol Endures: Public Menorah Lightings Withstand
Controversy, Antisemitism, Pandemic
Community 22 Synagogue Spotlight
24 Calendar
25 Obituaries
In every issue
4 Weekly Kibbitz
9 Jewish Federation
10 You Should Know
11 Nation / World
20 Food & Dining
23 D’var Torah
27 Last Word
28 Classifieds
Sending love and peace to your family
during the Festival of Lights.

Cover: Longtime 6abc anchor Jim Gardner prepares
for his final sign off
6 Josh Shapiro transitions to the 7 Beth Chaim Reform
governor’s office
Congregation selling banned
books 17 A symbol endures: Public
menorah lightings
withstand controversy,
antisemitism, pandemic
JEWISHEXPONENT.COM 3